"In the world ye shall have tribulation: but be of good cheer; I have overcome the world." –John 16:33

San Pedro Garza Garcia

College football helps academics?

This morning on my way into work, I listened to one of the most inane conversations I have heard in a long time.  The “Sports Director” at the WPTF radio station, a guy named Taylor Zarzour, talked about the great help winning football teams provide to the academic programs of universities like Duke, NCSU, and UNC.  He explained that not only do the television networks give the universities two or three free minutes to say anything they want about their schools during the course of a football broadcast, but they build great academic infrastructure like the new study facility inside the sports training complex at one of our local universities.  What is the purpose of that study facility?  To give the student athletes and only student athletes a place where they are required to study with mandatory tutorial help.  His thinking is that kids on the football team are not as well prepared for the rigors of university academic life as the kids who come to the university for purely academic reasons.  Wow!  So the universities are somehow improved academically by helping football players limp through degrees in communications studies, sociology, and psychology on their way to the NFL or, more realistically, into jobs as high school football coaches?  My mind is boggled.

Our whole educational system is broken.  Children leave the government schools with an abysmal education.  Thomas Sowell wrote an article for Townhall.com about the absurd fact that amateurs do a much better job than professionals when it comes to the education of their children.  After high school, we push kids into college who really should not be there.  Charles Murray writes of people with IQs of 100 or higher in a Wall Street Journal article, “Today’s simple truth is that far too many of them are going to four-year colleges.”  Read the article.  He makes a very cogent case for more vocational training and less university training.  So we should use football to attract people to the university who would be better served somewhere else?  In my experience, those attracted to the more rigorous academic disciplines such as engineering, math, physics, and chemistry seem to go to the best school that will accept them without regard to the quality of the football team.  None of them have much time to watch football anyway.  They are busy studying at the dorm or in the library.

Previous

Surreal moments in homeschool History and Psychology

Next

Miss Turbone is coming for Christmas

6 Comments

  1. Karen

    Very entertaining! Glad they got your weary mind going this am!! Did mine! If more kids went vocational — they’d make more money too!! Jay (a high school drop out) has college grads working under him because can’t find jobs with their majors. Had they gone to vocational school would be making more than him than him and probably be his boss! (Sounds backwards to me!) I would say though that we don’t have our kids in gov’t school for acedemia, but for people skills – it is a great place to learn that and quite quickly!

  2. Dad

    Very thoughtful post Karen. Your kids are a great case in point. They are very, very bright (I don’t know any other kids who had the skill set to build every last stick, pipe, and wire in a house before they were 12), have the energy and ability to start their own business, etc., etc. The thing that makes them such a great example is that they would do fine in college, but college might just hold them back from getting started with what they really want to do in life.

  3. Karen

    Well…Miles has surprised us! He’s finishing HS in spite of all the academic trials! and is applying to universities for a BSN (4 yr nursing)!! Would have never thought to choose that for him, but he’d be excellent at it – so GO MILES! (I see I should have re-read my earlier comment – I need to go back for a refresher in English! LOL!)

  4. Dad

    Nursing is a great career. He will be able to live anywhere he wants and make the BIG bucks. That is a super career choice.

  5. Lyle

    A good football program makes money. Also helps a few get professional football careers.

  6. Dad

    We are in complete agreement, Lyle. I should have paid more state to my physical condition my weight loss line would not be dropping like a rock. Both you and Brad are going to beat me if things keep going this way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén